Somewhere in San Jose, Calif., devotees of all things Facebook have gathered to celebrate the cult of Mark Zuckerberg and the little company he started. Dave McClure might call it his Graphing Social Patterns conference, but we all know it’s all about Facebook, Silicon Valley’s Furby. And while the fanboys gather and rejoice, they should also pay heed to some of the red flags fluttering in the hot air.
The company apparently sent out an email earlier this month informing all those who applied for grants via the fbFund to start over. We emailed Facebook to check the authenticity of the email, but had not heard back from them at the time of posting. (Given that there is a Facebook app for the application process, we take that as a confirmation.)
The fbFund was unveiled at the TechCrunch 40 conference last month, and as part of the announcement, Facebook backers Accel Partners and Founders’ Fund earmarked $10 million in new funds to give out to app developers as “grants” of between $25,000 and $250,000 each.
“It has become clear that we will receive proposals which contain similar or even identical ideas. As a result, and in order to protect other developers and us from claims that we or anyone else copied material without the creator’s permission, unless we agree otherwise in writing, we can’t promise that any materials or information you submit here will be kept confidential, or specifically that we or others might not develop similar or identical products or services. To make sure that everyone understands the conditions of submitting a grant application, we will not review any materials you have sent via email, and any materials you may have sent have been deleted.”
However well-meaning their intentions are, if the email is indeed authentic, then let me point out the obvious: the Facebook brain trust didn’t think through the implications of their announcement, and rushed to the podium, literally and figuratively. That deserves an “F,” especially for a startup that promises to be social operating system.
Is this a one-time oversight, or part of a pattern? The latter seems to be the case. Previously, the much hyped start-up botched up the launch of a smart feature (news feed), that caused a ruckus and a short-lived backlash. Luckily they dodged the bullet that time. Similarly, at the launch of the Facebook platform, the company showed its organizational ineptitude, keeping partners on tenterhooks.
Launch partner companies have been struggling to deal with uncertainty and last-minute changes to the tools and services made available by Facebook, multiple sources have told GigaOM.
Remember that when Facebook was subpoenaed a few weeks ago by the New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo over issues of “safety,” what got the political opportunist riled up was that the company “ignored” complaints from undercover investigators about “inappropriate sexual advances to underage users.”
The veracity of the charges is up for debate, as commentators in response to my previous post let me know, but regardless: you don’t just ignore complaints from an AG. It was a huge tactical blunder. Add in the fbFund fracas – you can feel that something is not right here.
These repeated botch-ups are signs that the wheels on Facebook, arguably one of the fastest growing startups in Silicon Valley are starting to wobble. Or maybe the autocratic Zuckerburg is a cat with nine lives.
Two Facebook-related blog posts I recommend:
Web
social
networks
Facebook
Featured
Technology-News
fbfund
During his keynote conversation with Michael Arrington this afternoon at the TechCrunch40 conference, Facebook founder and CEO Mark Zuckerberg announced that the company will be launching a new entity called fbFund with Accel and Founders Fund.
The size of the fund will be $10 million (coming from Accel and Founders Fund) with anywhere between $25 to $250 thousand in grants available for each selected startup dedicated to developing Facebook applications. Founders Fund and Accel will get the right of first refusal for the first round of financing of any company in the fund.
Peter Thiel of Founders Fund and Jim Breyer of Accel will be involved in the fund. Josh Kopelman of First Round Capital, founder of LinkedIn Reid Hoffman, Rajeev Motwani of Google, and Mark Zuckerberg himself will be on fbFund’s board of advisors. Chamath Palihapitiya, VP of Product Marketing and Operations of Facebook, will be handling fbFund internally for Facebook
Zuckerberg’s announcement comes two months after Bay Partners decided to earmark millions of dollars for investment in Facebook applications. Bay Partners’ prospects will certainly be diminished as the result of Facebook’s move to fund applications built on its own platform.
Crunch Network: CrunchGear drool over the sexiest new gadgets and hardware.